Modi’s India and the Manufactured Enemy: How Nationalism Now Thrives on Hatred, Not Peace

 

In today’s India, nationalism has been reshaped—not around unity or progress, but around a carefully constructed enemy: Pakistan. 

A New Nationalism for a New India?

Over the last decade, under Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s leadership, India has undergone a seismic ideological shift. Once a beacon of pluralism and secular democracy, India is now more closely associated with an assertive, Hindutva-driven nationalism—where political identity is defined as much by who you oppose as by who you are.

And at the center of this transformation? Pakistan.

From the Border to the Ballot Box

The 2019 "Balakot airstrikes" and the 2025 recent airstrikes were not just military actions; they became political and media spectacles. These events were heavily publicized as proof of India’s resolve, and Modi’s government framed them as watershed moments of strength and deterrence.

But this narrative of supremacy has come with consequences. The hyper-nationalism that followed left little room for introspection or dialogue. It has deepened hostility, silenced dissent, and created an environment where questioning military action is branded as anti-national.

During election seasons, anti-Pakistan sentiment has routinely been deployed as a tool to galvanize voters. Media outlets—with notable exceptions—have amplified this posture, framing Pakistan as both the source of India’s problems and a useful distraction from domestic challenges like unemployment, inflation, and rising inequality.

Bollywood as a Battleground

Popular culture has not remained untouched. Bollywood, once celebrated for its cultural pluralism, has increasingly mirrored the prevailing political climate. Films that glorify Indian military action and vilify Pakistan have seen both box-office success and political endorsement. Pakistani artists have been banned, and themes of Indo-Pak friendship have largely disappeared from mainstream cinema.

This shift has contributed to the normalization of hostility, where even fiction serves to reinforce the narrative of the enemy across the border and the heroism of unquestioning patriotism. The arts, traditionally a space for nuance and bridge-building, are now frequently enlisted in the service of state-sponsored nationalism.

Extremism in Power

Perhaps most concerning is the growing presence of individuals with extreme religious ideologies in the Indian political mainstream. Several ministers and elected officials openly express views that were once considered fringe—promoting majoritarian supremacy, rewriting history, and undermining the secular fabric enshrined in the Indian Constitution.

Laws targeting specific communities—are seen by many as part of a broader agenda to reshape the nation’s identity along Hindu nationalist lines. Dissent is increasingly met with legal persecution, surveillance, or vilification by partisan media.

Ceasefire as a Trophy, Not a Triumph

The most recent ceasefire agreement between India and Pakistan should have been a moment for both nations to exhale—a rare window for peace in an otherwise hostile relationship. Yet the reaction in India underscored just how deeply the supremacist narrative has taken hold.

Rather than celebrating the prevention of further bloodshed, many media outlets and politicians portrayed the ceasefire as a sign that Pakistan had "backed down" or "requested peace." This framing ignores the mutual nature of the agreement and reduces a humanitarian achievement to a zero-sum game.

It’s a shame when saving lives is viewed through the lens of conquest. Whether Indian or Pakistani, the real victory lies not in political point-scoring but in the simple, profound act of halting violence. As human beings, we should all celebrate the saving of lives—not weaponize it for narrative control

Conclusion: A Nation at the Crossroads

India today is a country of contradictions. It is a growing economic power with a vibrant democracy, but also one where democratic institutions are under strain. It speaks the language of global leadership while alienating its neighbors and deepening domestic fault lines.

The recent political and media responses to cross-border tensions and internal security events have further cemented one dangerous narrative: that India has one eternal enemy—Pakistan. This idea, fed persistently by the BJP and Prime Minister Modi’s political apparatus, has taken deep root in the national psyche. It is not just a policy stance but a collective belief system, instilled through repeated messaging, cinematic portrayal, and educational narrative.

In Modi’s India, peace with Pakistan is no longer an option that politicians dare to consider. Reconciliation is seen as weakness, dialogue as betrayal. And in Modi’s imagined version of Pakistan, there is no space for common humanity—only a caricature of perpetual threat.

National unity built on hatred is fragile; regional dominance achieved through intimidation is temporary. For India to truly lead, it must reconcile strength with compassion, and progress with pluralism. Until then, peace will remain an illusion—sidelined by politics, suffocated by prejudice.

True leadership is not about winning battles—it’s about preventing them.


Comments